SLEEP LONG, MY LOVE (1959) by Hilary Waugh


Waugh was one of the founding fathers of the American police procedural, following on from Lawrence Treat and Sidney Kingsley and paving the way for the likes of Ed McBain. His best and most widely read book remains the classic Last Seen Wearing, but the later Sleep Long, My Love is also very good and introduced his series character Fred Fellows, Chief of the Stockbridge, Connecticut PD. The book was filmed soon after its publication by writer-director Val Guest as Jigsaw. It all starts with a break-in …

I submit this film/book review for Bev’s Vintage Mystery Challenge and Tuesday’s Overlooked Film meme over at Todd Mason’s fab Sweet Freedom blog.

“Now he knew he would have to kill her.”

Set between 26 February and 13 March 1959, this follows the detailed investigation into the discovery of the trunk of a female body hidden in the basement of a secluded, recently rented little house. The trouble is there are no identifying characteristics left, no idea how the woman in fact died or what happened to her ‘husband’ John Campbell, who may or may not have been her real husband (and whose name is probably fake – the initials on her luggage says ‘J.R.’). Even the lease has been stolen after a burglary, so there is no copy of the man’s signature. But why did her burn all but not all of the body? And why were both bedrooms used when only the man and woman had ever stayed there?

“I’ve heard of murder cases where you don’t know the killer, but this is the first one where you don’t even know the victim”

Fellows and Sergeant Wilks really have their work cut out for them and the fascination is in seeing how they start with an apparently impossible situation, but slowly and surely manage to bring together a variety of seemingly insignificant details (initials on a suitcase, a dent in a car, a scrap of paper) to get closer and closer to finding a solution – topped by a neat twist that is a genuine and welcome surprise. There are weaknesses though, most notably the subplot about another woman, who also has the same initials as the victim and whose name is found on a piece of paper in the house and who it transpires also passed the night with the murderer. While well embedded in the final unravelling, it is also just a bit too convenient and contrived. But for the most part this is an exciting and low-key investigation, simultaneously banal in its every day detail but riveting in its storytelling – a very neat trick.
The Fred Fellows Mysteries

  1. Sleep Long, My Love (1959)
  2. Road Block (1960)
  3. That Night It Rained (1961)
  4. Born Victim (1962)
  5. The Late Mrs. D. (1962)
  6. Death and Circumstance (1963)
  7. Prisoner’s Plea (1963)
  8. The Missing Man (1964)
  9. End of a Party (1965)
  10. Pure Poison (1966)
  11. The Con Game (1968)

The film version relocates the story from Connecticut in the US to Brighton on the British coast but is otherwise remarkably faithful. Jack Warner, then already well-established as TV’s favourite copper in Dixon of Dock Green (BBC, 1955-76) plays Fellows and Ronald Lewis is Wilks. Val Guest handles his story with his usual tight control and understatement (there is no music), while the use of real location is a major selling point.

To stop the telling being too pedestrian and repetitive, Guest deploys a number of nifty visual touches like a flashback signalled by a passing car suddenly changing colour to match the recollection of a witness; and a series of cuts from a succession of messages all conveyed by teletype, the machines seemingly asking and answering each other’s questions. The cast is generally very capable, though Yolande Donlan (Mrs Guest in private life) is a bit hard to believe as the mousey and inexperienced girl who has a fit of hysterics when told she spent the night with a killer (and his dead victim in the room next door). John Le Mesurier on the other hand is very well cast against type as the seemingly stern father of the murdered woman who crumbles completely on hearing of her death. Together with Hell is a City (1960) and 80,000 Suspects (1963, I reviewed it recently here), Jigsaw forms a loose trilogy of manhunt thrillers all made on location around the British isles (Manchester, Bath and Brighton respectively) and all written, produced and directed by Guest in gleaming black and white CinemaScope. All are available on DVD or Blu-ray and are well worth rediscovering.
Mystery movies by Val Guest

  • Mystery at the Burlesque (1949)
  • Break in the Circle (1955)
  • They Can’t Hang Me (1955)
  • The Weapon (1956)
  • Hell is a City (1960)
  • The Full Treatment (1960) – review here
  • Jigsaw (1962)
  • 80,000 Suspects (1963)- review here
  • Where the Spies Are (1967)
  • Casino Royale (co-d, 1967)
  • Assignment K (1968)
  • The Diamond Mercenaries (1976)
  • Dangerous Davies: The Last Detective (1980, TV Movie)

See the excellent review by Holger Haase of this film over at the Hammer and Beyond blog. My dedicated microsite on Hammer Studios and its thriller films is here.

DVD Availability: Recently released on DVD in the UK


by Renown in a very decent anamorphic widescreen edition that offers a mostly very good print with only a few scratches here and there. There is also a Blu-ray released in the US by Cohen.

Jigsaw (1962)
Director: Val Guest
Producer: Val Guest
Screenplay: Val Guest
Cinematography: Arthur Grant
Art Direction: Geoffrey Tozer
Music: [none]
Cast: Jack Warner, Ronald Lewis, Yolande Donlan, Moira Redmond, John Le Mesurier, Michael Goodliffe, Christine Bocca

I submit this review for Bev Hankin 2015 Golden Age Vintage Mystery Challenge bingo in the ‘published in the year of a loved one’ category as this came out in 1959, when my cousin Simon was born:


***** (3.5 fedora tips out of 5)

This entry was posted in 2015 Vintage Mystery Challenge, Hilary Waugh, New York, Police procedural, Tuesday's Overlooked Film, Val Guest and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

32 Responses to SLEEP LONG, MY LOVE (1959) by Hilary Waugh

  1. Margot Kinberg says:

    Waugh was much more influential that we sometimes remember, Sergio, so I’m glad you featured this one. I think he did that bit-by-bit, police procedural approach to solving the crime very effectively, and I’m glad you see it here. I’ll confess I’ve not seen the film, but I am glad to hear that it’s more or less faithful to the book. As always, thanks for a thoughtful and interesting discussion of both book and film.

    • Thanks Margot – it had been decades since I read anythign by Waugh but am really glad I did. It is both a clever procedural and a good whodunit – not an easy thing to pull off!

  2. kaggsysbookishramblings says:

    Excellent piece and I hadn’t picked up that Jigsaw had a transatlantic source. I have Last Seen Wearing on the TBR, which I picked up when someone made the McBain connection – must dig it out…

  3. Colin says:

    I have the DVD since late summer but haven’t watched it yet – maybe over the holidays. The book sounds pretty good too so I may pick up a copy for reading afterwards.

  4. Patti Abbott says:

    I think I have only read LAST SEEN WEARING. Would love to see this film.

  5. JJ says:

    The idea of a simultaneous banal and compelling investigation brings to mind Ed McBain’s 87th Precinct books…not sure if that’s a valid comparison as I haven’t read this (or, really, enough of them), but no-one has made the dull quite as compulsive reading as McBain did. Whaddaya think, is it a fair association to draw?

  6. Yvette says:

    I’m intrigued, Sergio. I’ve never read any Hilary Waugh and probably I’m going to begin with this one if I can get a copy. Sounds like just the sort of thing I’d like. The movie sounds good too. But I don’t get to watch many of those anymore unless youtube has it or Amazon for rental. I’ll check around. I do like the old black and white English movies shot on location, most especially if they are good puzzlers. I trace my Anglophile tendencies to all the Brit b/w films I watched as a kid growing up in Manhattan.

    • I hope you get the chance Yvette – some of it might make you laugh admittedly (especially the scene with the woman who goes into hysterics who has to be borderline waterboarded to bring her out of it) but I think mostly it stands up very well.

  7. tracybham says:

    Both book and film sound good. Hilary Waugh is an author I have wanted to try, but as yet have no books by him.

  8. Bev Hankins says:

    Sounds good, Sergio. I’ve read Last Seen Wearing (from the library)–but it’s been a good while. I did enjoy it enough to buy a copy for myself and stick it back on the TBR.

  9. I’ve only read the classic Last Seen Wearing – so thanks for the introduction to the rest of his work. Film sounds intriguing too….

  10. neeruahcop says:

    Happy to have discovered this series, Sergio. Agree with you about the subplot.

    Hope all is well.

  11. Pingback: Forgotten Book: Sleep Long, My Love by Hillary Waugh (1959) – a hot cup of pleasure

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s