bfpdwlwcd05_all_consuming_fire_image_largeThis audio production is an adaptation of the 1994 novel by Andy Lane that brought  together Sherlock Holmes and, wait for it, Doctor Who. In addition there are also elements of the HP Lovecraft Cthulhu mythos too. Now, I realise that this may not appeal to all of you but this is a splendid treat and once you accept the premise of the pastiche, this audio never puts a foot wrong.

This review is offered for Todd Mason’s Tuesday’s Overlooked AV Media meme at his fab Sweet Freedom blog.

The Plot: The Library of St. John the Beheaded contains the most dangerous books in all creation so when some of them are stolen who else should the Vatican call but Sherlock Holmes?

Sherlock Holmes: “Confound that woman! Why will she insist on tidying? How am I supposed to find anything? One day someone will hang simply because Mrs Hudson sees fit to dust my bookshelves. While the rope creaks I will still be hunting for a valuable footnote or vital chemical formula sure in the knowledge that I could have placed my hand on it in seconds if only someone hadn’t moved it!”

The four-part, 2-hour production begins splendidly with Holmes and Watson on the Orient Express being flagged down by a nother train (one bearing the papal seal). It seems that three important books have been stolen from the Library of St John the Beheaded in Holborn (here in London, round the corner from my office as it happens) and the discovery was made by the Doctor, here appearing in his Seventh incarnation in the impish, endlessly surprising and always very welcome shape Sylvester McCoy (and yes, he is my favourite incarnation of the role, along with Matt Smith). When Holmes meets the Doctor there is a terrifically funny scene in which the great detective finds himself unable to practise his usual trick of determining where he deduces where his guest has come from (the contradictory evidence offered by the planet-hopping, time travelling Doctor of course scrambles and ultimately defeats Holmes’ methods).

From left: Hugh Fraser, Anthony May, Guy Adams, Samantha Béart, Nicholas Briggs, Sylvester McCoy, Michael Griffiths, Lisa Bowerman, Aaron Neil (image: Big Finish).

From left: Hugh Fraser, Anthony May, Guy Adams, Samantha Béart, Nicholas Briggs, Sylvester McCoy, Michael Griffiths, Lisa Bowerman, Aaron Neil (image: Lisa Bowerman / Big Finish) –

They are soon able to determine that Baron Maupertuis must be the one responsible for the stolen books, which it turns out hold important information about a portal to another dimension collected decades earlier by Holmes’ father (leading to the introduction of Sherlock’s ailing older brother Sherringford). This sees the team head off to India and a meeting with the Doctor’s archaeologist friend and sometime travelling companion, Bernice Summerfield (the star of her own series of books and audio adventures, played as ever by Lisa Bowerman). For once, on meeting the great duo,  the unflappable Bennie is actually pretty impressed:

Bernice Summerfield: “Sherlock – honest to god though, why is he not wearing that hat? – Holmes and John Watson, of course! He’s vaguely hot in a tweed and moustache and ‘kippers for breakfast’ sort of way.”

At this point Bernice (who is passing as ‘Bernard’ to avoid problems with the sexist times) takes over the narration from Watson and the story becomes less like a Holmes case and more of a Doctor Who adventure as we catch up with Ace, the Seventh Doctor’s companion at the time, who is on another planet, one that Maupertuis apparently intends to conquer in the name of the British Empire.

Bernice Summerfield: “Stopping the humans from invading the aliens –  makes a change”

What we have here is a real extravaganza, a mashup of two very different icons of pop culture, but ones that are resolutely British, which makes the satirical jibes at the Empire treatment of aliens even more piquant. More importantly, the characters are all treated with respect and one really can’t see the join, which is a very neat treat indeed and one well worth savouring. It helps of course that the Big Finish audio company already produces new Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Who adventures and importing the casts (and their respective theme tunes too) works superbly. And for Sherlockians out there that might be doubtful, it is I think worth pointing out that Lane has gone on to prove his form by becoming the author of the well-received series of Young Sherlock novels.

Ace: “Dream on, Shirley!”

I recommend this production without reservation – with its humour and vigorous high spirits and a globe and galaxy-trotting plot involving secret societies, papal libraries and spontaneous combustion, it is a delight from start to finish. My blogging friend the Puzzle Doctor reviewed this one over at In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel and liked it pretty much as well as I did, if you need any more convincing. To find out more about the production and several behind-the-scenes photos (such as those included in this review), see Can Scott’s homepage at:

To order this production on CD or as a download visit the Big Finish website at:

Sylvester McCoy and Nicholas Briggs (image: Lisa Bowerman / Big Finish) –

Director: Scott Handcock
Producer: Scott Handcock
Script: Guy Adams
Music: Alistair Lock (themes by Jamie Robertson and Ron Grainer)
Sound Design: Alistair Lock
Running time: 120 minutes
Cast: Sylvester McCoy (The Doctor), Nicholas Briggs (Sherlock Holmes), Richard Earl (Doctor John Watson), Sophie Aldred (Ace), Lisa Bowerman (Bernice Summerfield), Hugh Fraser (Sherringford Holmes), Anthony May (Baron Maupertuis), Aaron Neil (Tir Ram), Samantha Béart (Mrs Prendersly/Azazoth), Michael Griffiths (Ambrose), Guy Adams (K’Tcar’ch).

***** (4.5 fedora tips out of 5)

This entry was posted in Andy Lane, Audio Review, Big Finish, Doctor Who, England, India, London, Scene of the crime, Sherlock Holmes, Tuesday's Overlooked Film. Bookmark the permalink.

24 Responses to ALL-CONSUMING FIRE by Andy Lane

  1. Margot Kinberg says:

    It certainly sounds like fun, Sergio, for those who are willing to let go their disbelief and go along with the pastiche. And I am glad you found it so entertaining. Must confess it’s not for me, I’m afraid. But still, it sounds fun, and that’s what matters.

  2. realthog says:

    I’m so glad you like this — doubly so, since Andy Lane is one of the nicest of guys.

  3. Thanks for the plug. I was pretty sure you’d love this one too.

  4. Colin says:

    Not really a Who fan but I have to say that sounds like quite a bit of fun.

  5. Todd Mason says:

    Life will have its way with us. Meanwhile, as someone who has enjoyed Sherlockian mash-ups and recastings runniing at least from Manly Wade Wellman’s through Michael Chabon’s, the only downside I could see here is in not actually seeing Ms. Bowman perform.

  6. Not my thing at all, but you make it sound a delight, and I’m glad you enjoyed it!

  7. tracybham says:

    I love the idea of combining Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Who, although I have very little experience with either. Sherlock Holmes I have only seen in TV shows and movies. Have read one short story. And Dr. Who, have seen maybe one episode.

  8. Ed says:

    That sounds good. Another connection is that Steven Moffat is the producer of both Dr Who and Sherlock.

    • Absolutely true and of course Mark Gatiss no only connects the two but also works on a lot of the audio produced by Big Finish – yes, it is all coming together very nicely 🙂

  9. Like Tracy, I like the idea of a Sherlock Holmes-Doctor Who combo though I, too, have seen one or two single episodes of the latter. This definitely sounds entertaining, Sergio. Thanks for a fine review.

  10. These mashups are getting crazier all the time, and more out of hand.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s