W is for … WOBBLE TO DEATH (1970) by Peter Lovesey

The 2011 Alphabet of Crime community meme hosted by Kerrie over at the Mysteries in Paradise blog is nearing its conclusion. This week it reaches the letter W – and my nomination is …

WOBBLE TO DEATH by Peter Lovesey

“His rivals regarded him with the look of bemused indifference that cows give to passing trains.”

Spectator sports, class distinctions and the mores of Victorian society are all artfully combined with a clever whodunit in this prize-winning debut novel by Peter Lovesey, which was greeted by no less an authority on historical crime fiction than John Dickson Carr as a “first-rate story of sustained thrill”. First published over 40 years ago, this mystery with a smattering of social satire thrown in still holds up extremely well.

The setting is the Agricultural Hall in London in November 1879 and all the action is set during a six-day endurance test, or ‘wobble’, at the end of which will be crowned the ‘Champion pedestrian of the World’. The competitors (inevitably for the period they are all men), with only occasional breaks, will have to walk hundreds of miles round the less than salubrious indoor track until by the end of the sixth day the person who has walked the farthest (and is still standing) will win a prize of £500. Appropriately enough perhaps, and typical of this author’s sly cunning, the book itself grew out of a contest initiated by Macimillan with a prize of £1,000. Lovesey was the winner of the contest, selected from around 250 submitted manuscripts, and is still hard at it today (he is currently in the US promoting his latest ‘Peter Diamond’ mystery). This debut also introduced the adventures of Victorian policeman Detective Sergeant Cribb and his sidekick Constable Thakeray and its success led to a revival in the fortunes of the historical crime novel.

Although there are inevitably some similarities with Horace McCoy’s depression-era classic They Shoot Horses Don’t They?, there is nothing as grimly deterministic in its social commentary here as we follow the shifting fortunes of the contestants. Though there are 16 competitors to begin with, right from the start all eyes are on the rivalry between reigning champion Captain Erskine Chadwick, who from his side bets stands to win a whopping £11,000, and the young pretender Charles Durrell. Their contest takes place in a privileged space on the internal track reserved for gentlemen, while on the outer track run all the others from the lower social classes – the most eccentric of which is the completely inexperienced Francis Mostyn whose motives for participating are a mystery. At the end of each day we are given a summary of everyone’s progress with a table of the miles and laps run. Lovesey spends quite a lot of time setting up the basic situation and all the characters so that sergeant Cribb only makes his appearance a third of the way in when Durrell dies, apparently of tetanus. He is a serious and intelligent man, not much interested in running as a sport and who proves to be a smart judge of character, changing interrogation technique depending on the person in question. Cribb’s deductions are always logical and plausible, though I’m still not entirely convinced about how fairly he solved the case (more about that below)

Although this is a long way away from CSI we are plausibly shown how the police quickly determine that the death was in fact caused in strychnine poisoning. There is a rich variety of suspects, from Durrell’s rivals on the track to their helpers on the sidelines, not to mention his lusty wife Cora. She quickly turns on Sam Monk, her husband’s trainer, as he was used to making a tonic with strychnine to help boost his runners – she has also been having an affair with him. But then Monk also does in suspicious circumstances and the whole event comes under even closer scrutiny as the ‘wobble’ in allowed to continue while Cribb investigates, leading to a couple of funny moments in which the burly Thackeray is forced to run alongside the competitors as he tries to get their statements, much to Cribb’s amusement. There is in fact much humour in the book as we follow the rivalries and peculiarities of the runners, the role of the press reporting on the run and the effect this has on the increasingly stressed organisers.

“They was at the Lyceum, watching Irving in some play about Venice.”

This is combined with a mass of fascinating and convincing detail on life in mid-Victorian London which is handled fairly well so we don’t feel that we are having to stop regularly to have some empirical historical research paraded before us before the plot can pick up again – the integration of the various elements is in fact pretty seamless. The conclusion is certainly an ingenious one, though not too complicated (there’s a very clever bit of misdirection regarding Cora’s love life) and I certainly didn’t guess the murderer – but I’m not sure I really could have done either, though this isn’t much of a criticism. What is best about the book is the way that it succeeds in convincingly bringing the customs and manners of the past to life through careful use of detail, both physical and linguistic, but also manages the even harder job of making it seem relevant to the modern-day. With its emphasis on the mob mentality of the spectators baying for blood at this ‘cruelty show’, one is reminded of such popular equivalents as Big Brother and X Factor-style popularity contests / talent shows. In addition the parts of the story dealing with the use of performance-enhancing drugs and the way that money dominates sport usefully reminds us that some aspects of modern living are not o modern after all and provide a fascinating range of alternative perspectives on contemporary themes and attitudes.

In all Lovesey went on to write 8 Cribb novels though in addition, when it was turned into a TV series (ITV, 1979-81) starring the dour Alan Dobie, Lovesey with his wife Jacqueline also wrote all the original scripts for the episodes not based on his novels. ‘Wobble to Death’ was adapted particularly successfully, thanks to strong direction by Gordon Flemying (father of actor Jason Flemying) and a script by the late, great, Alan Plater.

For more information on the author and his books, including his contact details, visit Peter Lovesey’s official website at: http://peterlovesey.com.

For details of the Cribb TV series, visit: www.sergeantcribb.com/

***** (3.5 fedora tips out of 5)

This entry was posted in Crime Fiction Alphabet, Peter Lovesey. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to W is for … WOBBLE TO DEATH (1970) by Peter Lovesey

  1. Patrick says:

    I must say my introduction to Lovesey was underwhelming to say the least- I read the Cribb novel “Mad Hatter’s Holiday” and really didn’t like it at all. However, I’m bound to read more Lovesey in the future, because the positive signs are quite promising.

    • Hi Patrick, good to hear your comments. I must admit, I’m a big fan of both Lovesey’s earlier historical mysteries and his more recent contemporary ones featuring Peter Diamond – I particularly recommend THE FALSE INSPECTOR DEW. To me he is like Bill Pronzini, one of the last great practitioners of the GAD craft who are still writing great books but have been around long enough to have started publishing when the likes of Ellery Queen, Agatha Christie and John Dickson Carr were still writing.

  2. Bev says:

    I think this was my first Lovesy book (and the edition that you picture first). I loved the Cribb stories for a while but then got bored with them or something. After several years, when I found another one, it just didn’t grab me the way they did when I first discovered them.

    Here’s my W: http://myreadersblock.blogspot.com/2011/06/crime-fiction-alphabet-letter-w.html

    • Hello Bev, I do think that the Cribb books do suffer a little bit from the fact that the protagonist is perhaps a little colourless but this is much less true of the new Peter Diamond series. I always recommend BLOODHOUNDS from the Diamond series (along with THE LAST DETECTIVE, but it gets confused with similarly titled books by Robert Crais and the Dangerous Davies series by Leslie Thomas) and the aforementioned FALSE INSPECTOR DEW – If you are not grabbed by those, definitely time to give up on Lovesey!

  3. Yvette says:

    I’ve just picked up STAGESTRUCK at the library, the latest Peter Diamond book by Lovesey. I’d never heard of this Wobble book, though I must say the title conjures up all sorts of interesting visuals – like being done in by a bowl full of jello.

    But I digress…

    I’ll add this title to my TBR list. Thanks for the revelation, C.

    • Death by jello – a truly psychedelic idea – I think there’s a Pink Panther movie in which Inspector Dreyfus dives into a swimming pool that’s been filled with the stuff – but that really is digressing! Your library sounds a hell of a lot more current than mine – i slink away in envy and contemplate death by dessert … Thanks for the bouncy thoughts Yvette! And I hope you really enjoy the Lovesey – there is only one of his that I found I didn’t care for which is pretty amazing average in a 40+ year career!

  4. puzzledoctor says:

    Definitely recommend Bloodhounds – http://classicmystery.wordpress.com/2011/02/14/bloodhounds-by-peter-lovesey/ but was a bit less impressed with False Inspector Dew – http://classicmystery.wordpress.com/2011/01/27/the-false-inspector-dew-by-peter-lovesey/ Bloodhounds impressed me enough to get a couple more Peter Diamond books that I’ll get round to sooner or later. Of course, it was you who gave me these recommendations…

    • It’s a fair cop! In my mind there is no question that Lovesey is one of the best plotters of the traditional mystery currently working. Really looking forward to getting my hands on ‘Stagestruck’, his new Peter Diamond book.

  5. Pingback: PETER LOVESEY. Wobble to Death (1970). « Only Detect

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s