K is for … KILLER’S CHOICE (1957) by Ed McBain

The Alphabet of Crime community meme over at the Mysteries in Paradise blog this week reaches the letter K. My contribution this week is made up of a quartet of the 87th Precinct mysteries by Ed McBain published before 1960 so as to also be eligible under the guidelines of Bev’s 2011 Mystery Readers Challenge. Today’s book is …


“Like on Dragnet?”
“Better than Dragnet” Kling said, modestly.

This entry, the fifth in the series, made two significant adjustments to the roster of characters courtesy of an appropriately dramatic departure and a major new addition to the team of detectives.

Set in June 1957, it follows two murder cases which criss-cross and ironically overlap but which are otherwise completely distinct and separate. Annie Boone is found shot dead inside the liquor store where she worked as a cashier, covered in alcohol and shards of glass in what appears to have been part of a frenzied but inexplicable destruction of the stock. Indeed the boss seems sorrier about the loss of his merchandise than of his faithful employee. That same night one of the 87th precinct’s toughest detectives, the violent and cynical Roger Havilland, sees a dazed young man sitting on the sidewalk outside a shop. Uncharacteristically he actually tries to help, but is repaid by a violent shove through the shop’s plate glass window. The detective’s carotid artery is severed by a shard of glass and bleeds to death while his assailant makes a fast getaway. The man had in fact just attempted to rob the shop and had been shot in the shoulder by the barely conscious proprietor as he escaped.

The exit of Havilland, a once decent cop turned into a corrupt egotists by the cruelty of criminal violence, overlaps with the introduction of Cotton Hawes, a seemingly cool and intelligent but also somewhat arrogant detective who transferred that same day over from the more genteel 30th precinct. Hawes initially makes a poor impression on his colleagues and things don’t improve when he makes a colossal blunder which almost costs detective Steve Carella his life. It is typical of the novel’s essentially humanist approach that we see the reactions to Hawes’ mistake – he knocked on the apartment door of the man suspected of killing Havilland so giving him warning of their presence and the time to shoot at the detectives and make his getaway – not through a senior reprimand or recriminations from colleagues but less formally and dramatically, with a series of scenes in which we see the men discuss the event with their friends and families after hours.

At the core of the book is a decent little whodunit but what emerges most strongly by the end is a multi-faceted, even prismatic, portrait of the victim. A young woman, a divorcee juggling work pressures as well as a young daughter and her own mother, she is presented in an admirably complex fashion as an ambiguous, elusive yet fascinating character. Like the central figure of Laura in Vera Caspary’s eponymous novel, she is seen through the eyes of a wide variety of friends and acquaintances, all of whom only highlight certain parts of her personality, homing only on those features that are most important to them.

What emerges therefore is a highly contradictory figure: an intellectual interested in ballet and literature to one but a drunkard to another; a fun but not especially bright daughter to her mother but an intellectual heavyweight to her ex-husband; a bar-room lush with an interest in a young man recovering from an accident that has left him blind and a pool-shark’s moll. A prim and proper girlfriend to one man and a home-wrecking mistress of a married man to another. In this sense the initially unclear meaning of the book’s title is eventually revealed to refer to the decision made by the murderer to extinguish one of the woman’s seemingly many lives, not caring about the impact it would have on all the others and the people it touched. It’s a theme that is particularly well-suited to a cycle of novels which itself offers not one but multiple perspectives on the investigative process.

Tomorrow this brief look at some of the cases of the 87th Precinct continues with Killer’s Payoff.

***** (4 fedora tips out of 5)

This entry was posted in 87th Precinct, Crime Fiction Alphabet, Ed McBain, Police procedural, Vintage Mystery Reading Challenge 2011. Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to K is for … KILLER’S CHOICE (1957) by Ed McBain

  1. Sergio – Oh, thank you for doing an Ed McBain novel! I’ve always liked Carella et al. One of the things McBain does so well in this one and in Money Money Money, among others, is give the reader a multifaceted portrait of victim. You’ve explored that so well here that I won’t elaborate, but I think we see the same thing in Money Money Money, too. I also like the “inside look” McBain always gives the reader at the interplay of relationships among squad members. Thanks for reminding me that it’s been too long since I read something from the 87th :-).

  2. Thanks for reading and especially for the kind words Margot – and you are absolutely right about ‘Money Money Money’, no question! I hope you like the next three ‘K’ blog posts too!

  3. Pingback: K is for … KILLER’S PAYOFF (1958) by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  4. Pingback: K is for … KILLER’S PAYOFF (1958) by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  5. Bev says:

    This is a marvelous review! I look forward to your others on McBain. I have one his novels sitting on my TBR shelf (‘Til Death [1959]). Not sure when I’ll get to it. I initially bought it because it’s one of the pocket size editions that I love. Now, I know I’ll have to give it a try.

    • Thank very much Bev. ‘TIL DEATH is another interesting change of direction for the series which take s a much more domestic approach – it was also adapted into a very weird episode of COLUMBO that was also an attempt to change the format a bit – personally I think the book is much more successful, and I say that as a HUGE fan of COLUMBO.

  6. Bill Selnes says:

    I have enjoyed several of the stories set at the 87th. No writer I have read created a better ensemble cast of characters and crimes.

    • Hello Bill, thanks for reading. It does seem amazing that he managed to stay pretty much on top of the field for all those decades – you can certainly feel the McBain fingerprints on anything from the excellent Mankell and Sjöwall & Wahlöö series to any modern police procedural on American TV you care to mention.

  7. Pingback: K is for … KILLER’S WEDGE (1959) by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  8. Pingback: The 87th Precinct mysteries by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  9. Pingback: LADY, LADY, I DID IT! (1961) by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  10. I finished reading Killer’s Choice a few days back. Typical Ed McBain style with a touch of great humor. But I was unhappy with the ending. Vespers is next on my list.

  11. Hank says:

    I need to reread “Killer’s Choice”–I’ve now opened up my storage container full of musty McBain paperbacks (the hardcovers must be elsewhere) and, as with many of the 87th novels, while I can remember the underlying story (in this case, the death of Havilland) better than the primary story (Annie Boone)

    I also do remember the subplot involving the introduction of Hawes, who, to me, was never as interesting a character as he was in this debut.

    In flipping through the opening pages, however, I’m tickled to read that this was the novel where Meyer missed the bar mitzvah of his nephew, Irwin the Vermin. One could compile an encyclopedia of recurring McBain characters; Irwin is unique because although he’s mentioned maybe a half-dozen times or so over the course of 50+ novels, I don’t think the reader ever actually meets him.

    • I know what you mean – Cotton seemed at one poined poised to share lead status with Carella but it never really happened and McBain seemed to tire of him pretty quickly. Years would go by before he would get any kind of prominence. Certainly the ironic exit of Havilland is what I remember mostly from this one, though the central mystery is a properly intriguing one. An early favourite, though after 4 years I am a little fuzzy on it and can;t see myself going back to these until I get through the next 20 in the series first! 🙂

  12. Colin says:

    My slow path through the series continues and I popped in to mention I’ve now finished this entry. I have to say i really zipped through the book and thought it very good indeed. I was fascinated by the wildly different perceptions of Annie Boone held by the various relatives, friends and acquaintances, it makes you wonder how we are viewed by others too and whether any of what we might consider mere isolated personality traits are taken as representative of us. Food for thought.
    I was impressed too by the sensitivity McBain showed in the passages involving Monica, the victim’s daughter, and the other characters’ interactions with her. Overall, a top book.

  13. Pingback: THE BIG BAD CITY (1999) by Ed McBain | Tipping My Fedora

  14. Pingback: Ranking the 87th Precinct Mysteries | Tipping My Fedora

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s